Skip to content
Sweet Potato Awesome Ice Cream Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Dairy Free, Egg Free, Vegan)

Sweet Potato Ice Cream Recipe (Vegan, Low Histamine, GERD)

I appreciate you sharing this online and with friends & family.

I am SO freaking pumped to share a delicious low histamine sweet potato ice cream recipe with you today. Get this! This is a recipe for vegan sweet potato ice cream, egg free sweet potato ice cream, truly corn free sweet potato ice cream, low histamine ice cream, GERD friendly ice cream, and a whole lot more. The grand takeaway is that you won’t need eggs, heavy cream (or heavy whipping cream), or a lot of other conventional ingredients.

Instead, I’m going to show you how to make sweet potato ice cream with an ice cream maker and a handful of very interesting ingredients. So, keep on reading and then, send me pics of your sweet potato ice cream so I can celebrate with you.

Also, please note that whilst this is an egg free + dairy free ice cream recipe, it’s HELLA delicious. Like, I just need you to not be scared off by the free-from nature of the recipe.

Sweet Potato Ice Cream Video (Watch for my reaction!)

It’s not often that I get to taste something for the video, so be sure to check this one out. Note: if you have cookies disabled etc. etc. etc., the video player doesn’t work. Ask me how I know.

Allergy Status

Free From: Wheat/Gluten, Dairy, Egg, Soy, Tree Nuts, Peanut, Fish, Shellfish, Sesame, Top 9 Allergens, Top 14 Allergens, Alliums, Apple, Avocado, Banana, Beans & Lentils, Berries, Buckwheat, Cane/Refined Sugar, Carrot, Celery, Cinnamon, Citrus, Coconut, Corn, Cruciferous, Garlic, Latex Cross Reactive Foods (H/M), Legume, Lupin, Mushroom, Mustard, Nightshade, Oat, Onion, Pea & Pea Protein, Potato (Nightshade Variety), Poultry, Red Meat, Rice, Seeds, Squash & Gourd, Stone Fruits, Strawberry, Tapioca/Cassava/Yuca/Manioc, Tomato, Yeast

Friendly To: AIP Paleo, EOE, GERD, Grain Free, Low FODMAP, Low Histamine, Migraine Diet (Cleveland Clinic & Johns Hopkins) Paleo, Vegan

  • Low FODMAP Reminder: Sweet potato has a general limit of 1/2 cup per day. Make sure your portion size works for your individual needs.

Tools Needed for Sweet Potato Ice Cream

If you opt for the fresh sweet potato method, or no-churn ice cream method, be sure to read those sections well, as they include the additional tools you’ll need. These tools are for the recipe as-is, and with an ice cream machine.

Ingredients for This Sweet Potato Ice Cream Recipe

Sweet Potato Awesome in Blender by The Allergy Chef
These freeze dried sweet potato slices from Sweet Potato Awesome are a legit game changer.

Ingredient Substitutions and Notes

First, let me be SO clear. As-is, this sweet potato ice cream recipe is loaded with sweet potato flavor (especially before the churn) and truthfully, the ice cream base tastes amazing before you even put it into the ice cream maker.

Second, these substitutes are all suggestions. I’ve not tested these options since I made this recipe something I can personally eat. If you know my story, you know I don’t have a lot of safe food due to my 200+ food allergies and food intolerances.

Third, swap at your own risk. The nice thing about ice cream is that it’s super duper forgiving and your ice cream machine can make up for stuff. So just be smart about it and you’ll be OK 🙂

Freeze Dried Sweet Potatoes

I use the Plain Awesome Slices from Sweet Potato Awesome. In fact, Josh (the super cool owner) sent me some so I could make this recipe. You can use another brand, but it needs to be freeze dried, not regular dried where it’s chewy, soft, and still has a high water content.

Now, if you want to make this sweet potato ice cream recipe with sweet potato puree, purple sweet potatoes, or regular sweet potatoes, it’s possible. A long time ago, I messed about and got it to work, but the ratios weren’t quite right. Not like how they are now.

Freeze dried sweet potato + water = essentially rehydrated sweet potato. If you were to make the swap, you’d need to cook your fresh sweet potatoes (or frozen sweet potato cubes), allow them to cool completely, then weight them.

Let’s say you have 300g of sweet potatoes. You’d use 300g sweet potato + 300mL water (to start). You can’t use my full amount of water if you’ll be using a different type of sweet potato. Also know that you’ll have different flavours in the end if you make the swap (not necessarily a bad thing).

All of that to say this: use the Sweet Potato Awesome if you want the same results. I’ve worked out the ratio PERFECTLY and you’ll get an awesome creamy texture. If you go another route, you’re going to need to tweak things until your ice cream base looks like mine in the video.

Water (Truly Corn Free of Course)

With all of my food allergies, truly corn free water is the only option for me. You can slightly alter the texture and alter the flavour of this sweet potato ice cream recipe by using cow’s milk (whole milk, etc.), or dairy free milk (almond milk, oat milk, rice milk, etc.) in your own ice cream.

However, if you were to use full-fat coconut milk or even coconut cream, you’d throw off the recipe because there’s already a fat component to help create that silky smooth soft-serve texture. Along the same line, you should also avoid heavy cream and heavy whipping cream to ensure the fat ratio is on point (the key to getting the creamy texture).

Vanilla Extract

You can use less of the organic vanilla extract. However, the flavour of this homemade ice cream is just so dang good, so leave it as is if you can. If you opt for less, use enough that vanilla is present since we aren’t going for hint of vanilla here.

If you can’t tolerate vanilla extract, you’ll need to use organic ground vanilla (not the same thing as vanilla bean paste) to taste. If you use ground vanilla, make sure it’s very well distributed in your ice cream base and not clumped together.

Organic Maple Syrup

With my specific dietary requirements, when I develop a recipe I can personally eat, I’ll use organic maple as the sweetener. Maple syrup is a liquid sweetener. You cannot swap this for a granulated sweetener (white sugar, dark brown sugar, maple sugar, date sugar, coconut sugar, etc.) and still have the same results.

Alternatively, you can swap this for another liquid sweetener such as organic honey or date syrup. However! Know that each of these liquid sweeteners will absolutely knock you out of classic flavor territory and push into experimental territory (and that’s not necessarily a bad thing).

Pink Salt

If you want to have a little extra fun with this recipe, the next time you make it, use a smoked salt instead.

Tiger Nut Oil

This is an oil that’s liquid at room temperature. You cannot swap this oil for an oil or fat that’s solid at room temperature (coconut oil, butter, vegan butter, tallow, etc.).

If you need to use a different oil, it should be one that’s neutral in flavour. I can’t make any suggestions because honestly, any other oils I’ve tried to use in my vegan nice cream recipes never turns out so great. The tiger nut oil (tuber, not a tree nut) really is the top choice.

Sweet Potato Ice Cream Recipe Directions (with pictures)

Alright, get ready for some super easy instructions. You can also watch the recipe video if you want to see all of this in action, and hear me talk about this recipe (which was so fun and a total change of pace considering I can’t eat most of the recipes I share).

Start by opening three bags of the Sweet Potato Awesome plain slices. Break them into large pieces and drop them straight into your blender.

Sweet Potato Awesome in Blender by The Allergy Chef
Just break up the sweet potatoes a bit as you pop them in the blender so they all fit.

Place your blender container on your kitchen scale and tare to zero. Add each of the other ingredients, one at a time, and tare between weighted ingredients.

Adding Water for Sweet Potato Ice Cream by The Allergy Chef
Adding cold truly corn free water.
Pouring Organic Maple Syrup Into Blender by The Allergy Chef
Adding truly corn free maple syrup.
Organic Vanilla Extract for Sweet Potato Ice Cream by The Allergy Chef
This is the truly corn free organic vanilla that I use. I also purchase their ground vanilla as well. Good times.
Adding Tiger Nut Oil to Blender by The Allergy Chef
Adding organic tiger nut oil (tuber, not a tree nut).

Once all of the ingredients are in, pop the lid on. Blend on high speed until fully combined. There’s a good chance that your blender will struggle a little (yes, even a Vitamix), so use your tamper to help move things along. Hopefully you’re using a high-powered blender, but it’s also not the end of the world if you aren’t. Just make sure the ice cream base is uber smooth.

Once you have a smooth sweet potato mixture, transfer it from the blender to your ice cream machine. Press the magic buttons to get the churning started and wait for your delicious sweet potato ice cream to be ready. This is legit one of my favourite dishes to make because it’s so dang easy (thanks to the freeze dried sweet potato).

Pouring Sweet Potato Ice Cream Base Into Ice Cream Machine by The Allergy Chef

To see the texture you’re aiming for, watch the video. You’ll be able to see what the ice cream base looks like, and how it transforms thru the churning process.

Once your ice cream is done, you can eat and enjoy. You can also smile because not only is your ice cream a fun color, but it’s got a nice hit of vitamin A along with several other nutrients. Plus, I’m pretty sure that everyone you share this sweet potato ice cream with is going to love it.

Leftover Sweet Potato Mixture by The Allergy Chef
Use small jars to store leftover ice cream base, or finished/churned ice cream.
Sweet Potato Ice Cream Churning by The Allergy Chef
This is what your ice cream base should look like at the start of churning.
Sweet Potato Ice Cream Done Churning by The Allergy Chef
This is the sweet potato mixture, churned to ice cream perfection.

Now, if you’re wondering when to serve sweet potato ice cream, never forget, you can serve anything at anytime. Just because this recipe features sweet potatoes doesn’t mean you can only indulge in the autumn and winter. Like, seriously. Who cares what time of year it is. If you want peppermint candy at Easter and sweet potato ice cream in the summer, you’re doing just fine, so be sure to enjoy this delicious treat year round!

Sweet Potaot Ice Cream Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Gluten Free, Low Histamine, GERD, Top 9 Free)
There it is, in all it’s truly corn free, low histamine, GERD, top 9 & top 14 free glory. Silky smooth, uber creamy, custard-like sweet potato ice cream.

Need a No Churn Ice Cream Recipe?

Inherently, this sweet potato ice cream is a churn recipe, meaning you’ll get the absolute best results by using an ice cream machine. The reason: the air.

When you take dairy free, egg free, vegan ice cream, and pop it into an ice cream maker, man oh man. You can get some serious ice cream perfection, even without ingredients like egg yolks, and that’s why I’m always telling people to get one. Like, get ONE!!

Now, let’s say it’s not in your budget, you don’t make ice cream often, or you ordered on and you’re waiting for it to arrive but it’s going to be another week and you really want ice cream today. I got you.

Follow the recipe instructions. Rather than transfer the sweet potato mixture to the ice cream machine, you’re going to transfer your ice cream base to an ice cube tray. Honestly, you’re going to need a few ice cube trays, and silicone trays make the release easier.

Freeze overnight, because the cubes need to be solid. The next day, place frozen cubes into your high power blender with a little bit of milk of choice. Use the least amount of milk possible to get the blend to form properly. You’ll have a consistency that’s a cross between a smoothie and ice cream, but it will still be delicious.

Vegan Mashed Sweet Potatoes Recipe by The Allergy Chef (vegan, dairy free, top 9 free)

The Alternative No Churn Method

If you’d like something that’s closer to an ice cream machine, line a loaf pan with parchment paper (not aluminum foil since it will stick). Transfer the ice cream base to the loaf pan and pop it into your freezer. Set an alarm for 20 minutes. When the alarm goes off, manually mix the ice cream base in the loaf pan using a large spoon.

Put it back in the freezer and repeat several times. After about an hour or so, your ice cream should be a little more firm. Now, set the timer for 10-15 minutes. You’ll want to mix a little more frequently as it starts to harden.

Do that a few times and then set the timer for 5-10 minutes. Mix the base a few more times, then let it rest in the freezer for 1-2 hours. From there, you should be able to serve and enjoy.

Be warned, when using this method, ice crystals won’t form the same way as an ice cream machine, so stay on top of your mixing. Essentially, you’re a manual ice cream maker with this method. Also note that you may end up with uneven chunks in the end.

Food Processor Method

Some folks without an ice cream machine argue that the food processor method is better than the manual mixing method. Personally, I like the blender method the best, but just in case you don’t have one, here’s what you’ll do.

  • Follow the recipe instructions.
  • Transfer the ice cream mixture to ice cube trays rather than an ice cream machine.
  • Once the cubes are frozen solid, transfer a portion or two to your food processor.
  • Turn the processor on full mode (not the pulse mode) and add a milk of choice through the chute slowly. Do this until your have a mixture that resembles ice cream. It’s critical to pour the milk in slowly, or you’ll end up with a runny mess.

Sweet Potato Ice Cream Storage

OK, there are a few storage things we need to cover, so buckle up.

Standard Storage

You can make ice cream, eat what you’d like, then transfer leftovers to a freezer safe container and store in your freezer for up to 6 months. After 6 months, there’s a decline in quality and consistency.

Alternatively, rather than use one large bowl or container for freezing, use individual containers. This is what I do, and eating leftovers is a breeze.

Leftover Sweet Potato Mixture by The Allergy Chef

Ice Cream Base Storage

I’ve tested this recipe and when you eat the leftovers, they’re not as good as freshly churned ice creams. However, that’s kind of the general rule about free-from ice creams. They’re always going to taste EPIC when fresh.

If you have the time, make your ice cream base, churn, and enjoy fresh. Allow the ice cream to melt back down in the machine, then transfer it to a glass storage container. Pop that in your fridge, and enjoy fresh ice cream all week.

You can also store ice cream base containers in the freezer (I do this all the time). When you’re ready for ice cream, thaw the mixture completely, shake the jar like mad, then pour the base into your ice cream machine. Churn and enjoy.

Assembled Dessert Storage

If you make a layered dessert, ice cream sandwiches, or any other desserts where your sweet potato ice cream is part of an assembly, store it in the freezer in an air tight container.

You’ll usually want to enjoy your frozen dessert within 4 – 6 months.

Gluten Free Vegan Top 9 Free Sweet Potato Crumble by The Allergy Chef (Low Histamine)

More Awesome Vegan Ice Cream Recipes

If you’re a fan of nice cream, or simply need egg and dairy-free ice cream recipes, I’ve got you covered.

Vanilla Egg Free Ice Cream Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, Top 14 Free, Low Histamine, GERD Friendly) Vegan Gluten Free Ice Cream Brands and Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Corn Free Ice Cream)
Corn Free, Dairy Free, Refined Sugar Free Ice Cream Recipe by The Allergy Chef Creamy Dairy Free Avocado Pudding and Ice Cream by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, Top 9 Free)

How to Use Frozen or Fresh Sweet Potatoes in This Ice Cream Recipe

So I’ve touched on how to make the swap from freeze dried to fresh, but let’s take a deeper look so you know what you’re getting into. First, know that you’re taking a big leap by making this swap. However, it’s not like you’re leaping over a moat and there are hungry sharks waiting to get you. Instead, it’s a leap with a soft landing.

I’ll also add this: should you choose to use fresh sweet potatoes or frozen sweet potatoes, you really, really, REALLLYYYYYYYY should use an ice cream machine.

I don’t like to brag, but I’m like, a free-from ice cream expert. I’ve been testing different methods and ingredients for nearly two decades and I’m telling you, the ice cream maker makes ALL THE DIFFERENCE IN THE WORLD and it really is the best way to make homemade ice cream. ALLLLLLLLLLLL the difference. I can’t stress that enough. If you swap, and you use the no churn method, you’re going to have less than stellar results.

Squash for GERD Friendly Ketchup Going on Tray by The Allergy Chef

OK, back to how to get this done. Start by heating your oven to 400f/205c.

You can use regular sweet potatoes, Japanese sweet potatoes, purple sweet potatoes, and yams to do this. However, regular orange fleshed sweet potatoes and purple sweet potatoes are going to give you the best taste and texture.

  1. Wash the sweet potatoes.
  2. Peel the skin from your sweet potatoes.
  3. Using a large sharp knife, cut the potatoes down into medium to large cubes.
  4. Line a large baking tray (sometimes called a baking sheet) with parchment paper.
  5. Drizzle a little cooking oil of choice all over.
  6. Place the sweet potato cubes on the tray. Spread the sweet potato all over to form a single layer on the baking sheet.
  7. Oven roast at 400f/205c until fork tender (easy to pierce). There should be some brown caramelization on the sweet potato.
  8. Remove the baking sheet from the oven and allow the sweet potatoes to cool completely.

Now that you have oven roasted sweet potato, this is where the guessing game starts. The last time I made something like this for my taste testers, I used 500g squash + 600g Milk of choice. However, this was date sweetened, so the mass was different.

Start with 300g roasted sweet potato + 200mL milk of choice. Add all of the other ingredients, and blend. From here, keep tweaking the amount of sweet potato and milk until your ice cream base looks like mine from the video.

Notes & Tips

One of the best tips I can give you is this: Don’t use a square baking dish or anything of that nature since ideally, you want the sweet potato to form a single layer on a large baking tray (sometimes called a baking sheet).

When you do that, and have the caramelization, if you end up sharing your sweet potato ice cream, people are going to love that extra depth and you’ll get nothing but rave reviews and comments. Well, that and people are going to ask you for the recipe as well.

You don’t need to mash the cooled sweet potatoes with a dish like this because you’re popping them into the blender. It will take care of everything for you.

More Tasty Dessert Recipes (Gluten Free & Allergy Friendly)

Amazing Vegan Gluten Free Cake Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Top 9 Free) Top 9 Allergy Free Cake Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, GF, Low Histamine)
Bakery Vegan Snickerdoodle Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Gluten Free Cookies) Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Recipe Without Eggs by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, Top 9 Free)

Delicious Ways to Tweak This Sweet Potato Ice Cream

Lean Into Fall Flavors

This sweet potato ice cream recipe is at its core, safe for so many people because it’s so simple. However, you can add pumpkin pie spice, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, and other warm spices to change up this recipe. You’ll end up with a creamy ice cream that’s perfect for eating next to a fireplace.

Make Sweet Potato Pie Ice Cream

To make sweet potato pie ice cream, find a recipe online for sweet potato pie. Look at the spices (cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, etc.) and make a spice blend with those ratios. Add that to the blender and in the end, your sweet treat will scream sweet potato pie filling ice cream.

Gluten Free Vegan Truly Corn Free Sweet Potato Pie Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Grain Free, Top 9 Allergy Free)

Add Some Protein

You can add organic cashew pieces to the ice cream base and give your ice cream a protein boost. Cashews are pretty neutral in taste, so they won’t take over like how walnuts, almonds, or pecans might take over.

Personally, I wouldn’t use more than 100g of cashews. You don’t need to alter your instructions or churn time when doing this. Just be sure to make perfect scoops of ice cream that are Instagram ready and share your pics with me online.

Go With a Cone

As you can imagine, I don’t have a safe commercial ice cream cone. However, I’ve figured out how to make pretty rad truly corn free ice cream cones. You can serve your sweet potato ice cream in an ice cream cone, or in an ice cream cone bowl (also called a waffle bowl).

I have this little waffle bowl maker. I like it, but I’d love it more if it could make four ice cream cone bowls at once. It takes a little while to cook each waffle bowl, but, it’s also kinda worth it for the novelty effect. It’s also worth it if you have dietary restrictions and want the experience.

Once you have perfect scoops of ice cream in your bowls, add some toppings like mini chocolate chips or candied nuts/seeds.

On the left is a waffle bowl and on the right is a homemade truly corn free ice cream cone (grain free, top 9 free, etc.).

Creamy Dairy Free & Egg Free Vanilla Ice Cream Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, Top 9 Free) Creamy Dairy Free & Egg Free Vanilla Ice Cream Cones Recipe by The Allergy Chef (Vegan, Top 9 Free, Corn Free)

Purple Sweet Potato Ice Cream: The Easier Way

Did you know that you can purchase ube powder (purple sweet potato powder)? You can use some of that in the recipe as it is and it will tint your ice cream purple. Just be sure to get the ratio right, or you’ll end up with a weird colour.

Alternatively, use the fresh sweet potato method that I outlined and use purple sweet potatoes to make a sure delicious purple sweet potato ice cream.

Go With the Graham (not Instagram)

Ice cream and graham crackers are a tasty dessert waiting to happen. Serve scoops of your awesome sweet potato ice cream on a graham cracker crust base, and top with toasted mini marshmallows, or torched aquafaba fluff (watch the video on this recipe post to see the process in action).

Ooh! You can drizzle on some melted chocolate chips for a modern s’mores vibe.

Classic Cake and Ice Cream

If you love cake and ice cream together, but manage lots ot dietary restrictions, check out this ginger cake recipe, or this vanilla cake recipe. Talk about a tasty plate waiting to happen.

You’ll want to bake up your cake whilst your ice cream churns, then allow it to cool a little bit before serving.

Create a Layered Sweet Potato Dessert!

Have a solid bottom, like these refined sugar free shortbread cookies. The next layer can be something like sweet potato brownies, or even this pumpkin cake recipe. The next layer should be your sweet potato ice cream. Finally, add a drizzle of caramel sauce all over and now you’ve got one of the best sweet potato desserts on this side of the Mississippi. Well, my side, though technically, that could be read to imply your side as well.

Make Sweet Potato Ice Cream Sandwiches!

Bake up a batch of these vegan snickerdoodle cookies to use as the outside of your sandwich. Make sure the cookies have cooled completely before assembling, so bake them 1-2 hours in advance.

Once your sweet potato ice cream is done churning, build sandwiches. However, I want you to have so much fun, so use a small cookie scoop, medium cookie scoop, and large cookie scoop when making the cookies. This allows you to make cute little two bite sandwiches, but also to have some big ones.

You can even roll the sides of the sandwiches in toppings like sprinkles or mini chocolate chips (or mini white chocolate chips).

Answering Your Questions About Sweet Potato Ice Cream

Can I make the ice cream base in my food processor?

No, you won’t be able to make this vegan ice cream recipe in a food processor. You know how the food processor has that wide two sided blade? Rather than the four prong small blade like in a Vitamix?

That’s the issue. A food processor will get you small and large crumbs of sweet potato, but not a super smooth ice cream base, which is what you need for the best sweet potato ice cream experience.

Can I purchase freeze dried sweet potato at the grocery store?

Nope. I have never once in my life, even at the organic grocery store, seen freeze dried sweet potato. They carry other freeze dried fruits and vegetables, but sweet potato is just a special one.

You’ll either need to order a brand I don’t personally vouch for online, or grab bags of the Sweet Potato Awesome.

Could I use an immersion blender to make the ice cream base?

That’s going to be a hard maybe on the hand-held stick blender. The issue is that the freeze dried sweet potatoes need to be completely obliterated. It’s possible that with an immersion blender, you’ll still have little pieces of the sweet potato running throughout your sweet potato mixture. You know how some ice cream flavours come with swirls? You could do a little PR campaign on behalf of your ice cream and just call it a fall flavor swirl.

Ultimately, you can use a hand-held stick blender, but you need to go into that one eyes wide open and managing your expectations. Overall, your ice cream will function and can be churned, it just won’t be silky smooth like what I have in the video.

Do I need to cook the ice cream base before churning?

Great news!! There’s no cooking required, so long as you use the freeze dried sweet potatoes. If you opt for the alternative method, you do have some cooking. But, with the standard method, you blend, churn, scoop, and enjoy. Like, a LOT.

Will this ice cream have a custard consistency, or something else?

You’ll be happy to know that I’ve been able to secure truly corn free eggs and make a TCF egg yolk based custard ice cream. So, I absolutely have a point of reference for once (I usually don’t since I’m allergic to so much).

A custard forward ice cream has an almost “stretchiness” to it that I can’t quite describe. There’s also a beautiful creamy mass and it’s just so dang smooth when you eat it. It’s also very lickable in a soft-serve texture kind of way.

This sweet potato ice cream gets close! It doesn’t have the stretch, but it does have the uber creamy mass and the soft serve texture. It’s a little less lickable, and if you freeze your leftovers, you’ll see that fresh is best. I feel like with a proper custard forward ice cream texture, after it’s frozen, it’s still in the 90 percentile in terms of texture retention.

Full disclosure though, this sweet potato ice cream recipe is so delicious, you’ll want to eat like, the whole batch in one sitting, even though it’s not quite a custard style ice cream.

Can I use a nut butter instead of the tiger nut oil?

This is such a great question with an interesting answer. So, the tiger nut oil (tuber, not a tree nut) is a liquid fat at room temperature. What this means is that we want to stick to that when choosing a substitute.

A nut butter (almond butter, pecan butter, etc.) and even peanut butter, when you mix it is a combination of fat + mass (mass being protein, carbs, etc. in this example). So it’s not a pure fat like the oil is. This will have a couple of impacts. One, you’re using pure fat so the ratio is not a 1:1 substitute. Two, you’re adding flavour and additional mass to the sweet potato ice cream, and that may have a negative impact on the final churn. However, at just about 30g/1 ounce, it wouldn’t be a HUGE impact.

Interestingly, if you were to use the top oil of the nut butter (before you mix it and there’s that oil on top), then it would be a 1:1 substitute, however, that would also mess up your nut butter since it wouldn’t be properly mixed with the oil.

Now, a great alternative to a nut butter is a nut oil. Just how you can purchase pecan butter, almond butter, walnut butter, and so on, you can purchase the oils. Almond oil, and pecan oil would be my top two choices since the flavours won’t be too intense, and can compliment the sweet potato flavor. Walnuts can be pretty intense, so I’d avoid that oil, but to each his own.

If you really want to have fun with this, I’d suggest using pecan oil as a substitute, then, make a pecan butter + maple syrup + vanilla + nutmeg (just a little bit) “caramel sauce” (combine these ingredients together in a small bowl). Drizzle the faux caramel sauce all over and add an additional topping of crushed candied pecans. Talk about an interesting version of this dessert that will have you rethinking how you normally make ice cream.

No matter what substitute you end up going with, just be sure to grab a spoon and sample before transferring the ice cream base to your ice cream machine. If it needs some tweaking, that’s the time to do it.

Is pure maple syrup the same thing as organic maple syrup?

Yes and no. Organic maple syrup by default is almost always pure maple syrup. The only ingredient is maple syrup (well, there are processing aids that aren’t on the label, but you get the idea).

On the flip side, pure maple syrup isn’t always made with organic ingredients. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn’t. Additionally, some brands say pure, but when you read the label, there’s a little bit of something else present.

As long as you read the ingredient label, you’ll know which pure maple syrup is the best option, and without added ingredient, assuming you don’t want organic maple syrup.

Can this recipe be made with bananas instead of sweet potatoes?

Yes and no. The ratios are designed for freeze dried sweet potatoes. In theory, you could use freeze dried bananas instead (yes, that’s a thing). However, my tasters have all told me, several times, that freeze dried bananas just don’t stand up to fresh bananas.

The best way to make a proper banana nice cream is to use a ripe banana or two as the base, and build from there. Rather than use this recipe as a jumping off point, I’d encourage you to search online for a banana ice cream recipe that will meet your needs right out of the gate (vegan, Paleo, refined sugar free, etc.) Just be sure to put specialty terms into the search engine for the best chances at finding said recipe.

Is it OK to substitute vanilla paste for vanilla extract?

In theory, yes, but you’d have to look up the conversion rate. I don’t work with vanilla paste (also called vanilla bean paste) so I don’t know how strong it is, or how much to use when substituting. When in doubt, start with less than what you think you need, then sample the sweet potato mixture, then add more if needed.

Is non-dairy milk the same thing as dairy free milk?

Non-dairy (also written as nondairy) used to imply that there could be a very small amount of cow’s milk dairy in a product. Dairy free on the other hand means zero dairy. Period.

Whilst the regulation has changed over the years, the US FDA generally has the viewpoint that “non dairy” could contain up to 0.5% of dairy milk derivatives such as caseinate. Dairy free always meant zero milk or milk derivatives.

At the time of publishing in 2026, what I can tell you is this: many brands are using the terms as if they’re interchangeable. This can be confusing to a lot of people because you’re not sure what they’re referring to.

When in doubt, anyone with a milk allergy should always contact a company to better understand their ingredients and manufacturing process.